Home
View the profile
Who Knew
Smaller Than You
(Self Released, 2008)
Who Knew isn’t your bog standard ska-punk release. Not by a long shot, which is quite a surprise for a band as young as Smaller Than You. Instead, it’s actually a musically accomplished release that flits between brisk skank-ready numbers and calmed moments of steadiness. Add into the mix some jazz and a consortium of peripheral instruments, and you’re in the same ballpark as the band.
‘Can You Hear Me’, the stand-out track, probably sums the band up best. Composed upstrokes lead the way but a strong bass sound and some exemplary brass build this into something a bit more advanced. It’s almost like a jam session taking place in some smoky jazz club, a quirky charm resonating. ‘Open Minded’ is the leading example of the band at a quicker pace, bringing together a gang chorus and almost a ‘circus’ feel. This is the sound of a band having fun with what it’s doing.
As good as Who Knew sounds musically, there are also two recurring drawbacks to the EP. Firstly, the tracks tend to be a little overlong (not one song is under 3:40). Nobody will criticise a band for putting as much into a song as possible but there’s a definite feel that some of the tracks here, particularly the more up tempo songs, might have benefited from a bit of a shave. Secondly, the vocal doesn’t sit all that comfortably. It’s a little too lethargic at times, a little too plodding perhaps. In fairness, on repeated listens it tends to fit a little bit more each time, going some way to adding a certain amount of character to the sound.
There’s no doubt there’s talent on display here. Smaller Than You is definitely on the way to creating a sound all its own. It’s still not completely there, but points are definitely added for packing this release full of layers that can be stripped away, making each listen a little different to before. Encouraging stuff.
SkaMutiny Rating: 3/5
Al
